🕯 Toward the Light!

The Book › Commentary to Ardor's Account

Section XXVI

Judas did not kiss Jesus when he betrayed him.

Peter, who was impulsive and quick-tempered, struck one of the servants in the face in order to protect Jesus. The account of the sword and the severed ear is all legend.

Peter’s denial of Jesus is not included in Ardor’s Account, since it in no way plays the part ascribed to it by the Evangelists.

Jesus had often told the apostles that Simon Peter was appointed to be their leader when he himself had left them. Since Peter was of a quick temper, Jesus forbade him to accompany him when he was led to the house of the high priest, lest he should endanger himself or the other apostles by some impetuous action.

Peter’s grief over the imprisonment of Jesus was so great that he was unable to comply with this instruction and, unseen by Jesus, he stole after him and hid himself in the courtyard around Caiaphas’ house, so as to be as near as possible to his beloved master.

But at the moment he was questioned as to whether he was one of the Nazarene’s followers he remembered his pledge to be the apostles’ leader, and so as not to act against the wish of Jesus he saw no other course than to deny his acquaintance and relationship with him. Peter thus acted not out of fear for his own life, but out of fear of Jesus’ disapproval of his high-handed action.

Jesus’ prediction of Peter’s denial is fictitious, as is the account of Jesus’ subsequent thrice-repeated question: „Simon, son of Jonas, lovest thou me?“ (John 21:15–18).

Only excerpts from the high priest’s questioning of Jesus are given in Ardor’s Account, since the Gospels have preserved much of the proceedings more or less correctly.

The examination of Jesus by Pilate was essentially a repetition of the questioning by the high priest. Jesus answered him in the same way that he had answered Caiaphas.

The story about Barabbas is correct; he was set free in place of Jesus.

The account of the dream of Pilate’s wife is fictitious.